The Directorate-General for Migration Management (DGGM), in Spanish Dirección General de Gestión Migratoria, has published Guideline No. 6/2025, establishing that applications for the Permanent Residence Card for family members of a European Union citizen or of another State party to the European Economic Area Agreement shall be considered approved by positive administrative silence if no express resolution is issued within the legal period of three months.
💡 At ARC Legal Abogados, we maintain an active space where we continuously update all administrative guidelines, clarifying notes, and instructions related to the new Immigration Regulation. You can access it here: Immigration Regulation Hub.
⏺️ A clear and uniform guideline
This document aims to unify the practice of Immigration Offices and ensure the consistent application of the principle of legal certainty. Specifically, it determines that when an applicant has properly submitted their request and three months have passed without a resolution, the application shall be considered granted.
The DGGM bases this guideline on the First Additional Provision of Organic Law 4/2000, as well as on Supreme Court case law, which has already ruled in this regard in several decisions — notably those of 19 January 2022 (case 3501/2020), 2 February 2022 (case 5916/2020) and 13 July 2022 (case 946/2021).
All of them confirm that, if no resolution is issued within the established time frame, the administrative silence shall be deemed positive, implying the automatic recognition of the right to permanent residence.
⏺️ European legal foundation
The guideline is also supported by Directive 2004/38/EC, which governs the right of residence for EU citizens and their family members. This European rule recognises that the right of permanent residence arises directly from meeting the material requirements — mainly, five years of continuous legal residence — and does not depend on the formal issuance of the residence card.
Therefore, the absence of an administrative resolution cannot constitute an obstacle to the exercise of a right derived directly from European law.
⏺️ Practical application of the guideline
In practice, this means that if an applicant for a Permanent Residence Card as a family member of an EU citizen does not receive a resolution within three months from submitting their application, they may be considered a beneficiary of positive administrative silence.
In such cases, the applicant may request an administrative certificate confirming this effect, and the Immigration Office must issue it without reassessing the merits of the case.
Likewise, if the Administration issues a resolution after the deadline, it must respect the effects of positive silence, unless there are legal grounds for nullity or review.
⏺️ A step forward for legal certainty
This new guideline represents a significant step toward greater legal certainty and predictability in immigration proceedings. It reinforces the application of case law that protects the rights of EU family members and strengthens a rights-based interpretation of the immigration framework.
⏺️ Do you need legal assistance?
At ARC Legal Abogados, we advise and assist our clients in procedures related to the Residence Card for family members of EU citizens, including initial applications, renewals, and appeals against denials. If you are in this situation, our team can help you assess your case and determine whether your application falls under the positive administrative silence provision.
You can contact us through our online form.
Related posts
- New Management Guidance 5/2025: Medical Certificate requirement in residence applications from Spain
- DGGM expands Guidance 4/2025 on calculating irregular stay after asylum procedures
- Can I travel while renewing my residency in Spain? Everything you need to know about the “Autorización de Regreso”
Prefer to read this article in Spanish 🇪🇸? Puedes encontrarlo aquí: Residencia permanente como familiar de ciudadano UE: nuevo criterio a favor de los solicitantes
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Immigration regulations are subject to frequent administrative and interpretative changes. At ARC Legal, we make every effort to keep our content updated and aligned with official sources, but we always recommend consulting with a specialized lawyer before starting any procedure or making legal decisions. For personalized guidance, don’t hesitate to contact us.
